Old Towne Orange Real Estate: A Shifting Market, but Still a Strong One

By Angie Catale | Local Realtor & Old Towne Orange Real Estate Specialist with Lionheart Pride
If you’ve been keeping an eye on the real estate market here in Old Towne Orange, you’ve probably noticed things are changing. We’re seeing more homes available, buyers taking a little more time to make decisions, and a market that is beginning to shift toward buyers. But does that mean it’s a bad time to sell? Absolutely not!
The truth is, while the market may look different than it did a few years ago, Old Towne Orange continues to be a desirable place to call home, and sellers are still getting great prices for their properties.
What Are the Numbers Telling Us?
According to the October 2026 market report from the Pacific West Association of REALTORS®, ZIP code 92866, which includes Old Towne Orange, has seen some interesting changes.
Inventory of single-family homes increased 30% compared to October 2025, giving buyers more choices. The supply of homes also increased from 2.3 months to 3.3 months, indicating that the market is becoming more balanced.
But here’s the number I find particularly encouraging for sellers: Over the past 12 months, single-family homes sold for an average of 99.1% of their original asking price! That’s an increase from 96.7% during the previous 12-month period.
Even more encouraging, the median sales price for single-family homes over the past 12 months was $1,215,000, holding steady compared to $1,212,500 the year before.
What does that tell us? Although buyers have more options and a little more negotiating power, well-priced homes are still attracting buyers and commanding strong prices.
Interest Rates: The Challenge for Both Buyers and Sellers
One of the biggest challenges in today’s real estate market continues to be mortgage interest rates, and they’re affecting both sides of the transaction.
For buyers, higher interest rates mean higher monthly mortgage payments, which directly impact purchasing power. Buyers who could comfortably afford a certain price a few years ago may now find themselves needing to adjust their budgets, even if their income hasn’t changed.
But what many people don’t realize is that interest rates are also creating a challenge for sellers.
Many homeowners in Old Towne Orange purchased or refinanced their homes when interest rates were historically low. Some are enjoying mortgage rates around 2% or 3%. Even if they would love to move into a larger home, downsize, or relocate, giving up that low interest rate can be a difficult decision.
This has created what many in the real estate industry call the “lock-in effect.” Homeowners who might otherwise sell are choosing to stay put because they don’t want to trade their low mortgage payment for a significantly higher one.
As a result, even though inventory has increased, the number of homes available remains relatively limited.
Is It a Buyer’s Market or a Seller’s Market?
I would describe today’s Old Towne Orange market as a market in transition.
Buyers are finally gaining some breathing room. They may have more opportunities to negotiate, request repairs, or take a little more time to find the right home.
However, with just 3.3 months of single-family home inventory, we haven’t moved into what is traditionally considered a full buyer’s market. Sellers still have an advantage in many situations, especially when their homes are priced correctly, well-maintained, and marketed effectively.
The days of simply putting a home on the market and expecting multiple offers well above asking price may not be as common, but that doesn’t mean sellers aren’t doing well. It simply means that pricing, presentation, and having an experienced Realtor are more important than ever.
Why Old Towne Orange Remains Special
One thing that hasn’t changed is the appeal of Old Towne Orange.
From our historic homes and beautiful tree-lined streets to the charm of the Orange Plaza, local restaurants, shops, and wonderful community events, Old Towne offers a lifestyle that’s hard to duplicate.
People don’t just buy a house here. They buy into a community, and that continues to make our neighborhood special.
So, Is Now a Good Time to Buy or Sell?
My answer is that it depends on your personal situation.
If you’re a seller, don’t let headlines about a slowing market discourage you. Home values remain strong, and buyers are still purchasing homes. The key is understanding today’s market and positioning your property correctly.
If you’re a buyer, you may have opportunities that weren’t available a few years ago. More choices and greater negotiating flexibility can make this an exciting time to purchase, even with the challenges of interest rates.
After more than 20 years in real estate, I’ve learned that there is no perfect market. Every market presents different challenges and opportunities.
The Old Towne Orange market isn’t falling apart. It’s simply adjusting, and there are still great opportunities on both sides of the transaction.
As someone who lives, works, and is actively involved in our Orange community, I believe there is something truly special about this town. No matter what the market is doing, Old Towne Orange will always have something that statistics can’t measure: its charm, character, and incredible sense of community.
Angie Catale | Realtor
Lionheart Real Estate | DRE #01454264
Source: Pacific West Association of REALTORS®, October 2026 Local Market Update, ZIP Code 92866. Data provided by CRMLS. Statistics reflect single-family homes unless otherwise noted.
Have information about this story?
Contact the newsroom →